Why The Indian Mascot Issue is NOT a Case of “Political Correctness”
The recent NCAA ruling is the latest chapter in the ongoing issue of the use of Indian mascots. I would submit that this is not a case of political correctness, but rather an acknowledgement of the concerns of a group of Americans who have been attempting to make there voices heard for a long time.
Instead of making snap judgments based solely on our personal experiences and frames of reference, (which, I might add, is a perfectly natural thing to do), why not challenge ourselves to be truly open to the perspectives of others? If so many different people in the American Indian/Native American community have been expressing their deep dismay over the mascot issue, and doing so consistently over a long period of time, should not those of us in the “majority” get curious and interested in this, and be willing to listen?
Context is everything. I don’t think we can have a substantive conversation about the impact and meaning of these images unless we put them into the larger context of our nation’s history, and the current state of Native American/Indian affairs. To quote Dr. Martin Luther King, "Actually, we who engage in nonviolent direct action are not the creators of tension. We merely bring to the surface the hidden tension that is already alive. We bring it out in the open, where it can be seen and dealt with."
Similarly, the NCAA are not the creators of tension here, but the mascot issue is bringing to the surface the hidden tension between the majority and a largely “invisible” minority in our country. Instead of being dismissive of the concerns being expressed, why not ask ourselves what is at the root of them? I believe it is imperative that white people in the U.S. become willing to enter into a dialogue about the larger issues of concern to our Native American/Indian communities (as well as our other minority communities). We have not yet healed the wounds of our past, and until we face them fully, their legacy will reverberate and trickle down to all facets of our society.
Maybe looking at these realities makes some of us feel uncomfortable. But, we need not avoid the issue nor be defensive; we need only to be willing to listen with an open mind. Finally, I want to stress that this is NOT a liberal or conservative, “partisan” issue. I invite/challenge all white people in this country, Democrats, Republicans, and those from all other parties, to step out of our comfort zones and begin this dialogue in earnest. ###
(c) 2005 J.G. Boccella